The Origins of Islam - 7.2 The Shrine Archetype
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
In this video, we are looking at other Domes in Jerusalem, Palestine and the Greek and Roman worlds in general. We will look at the specific archetype which was also used for the Dome of the Rock and at what this may imply.
#Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Temple #Mount #Jerusalem #domeoftherock #Dome #Rock #Judaism #templemount
Reference for this episode:
Grabar, Oleg. The Dome of the Rock. Harvard University Press, 2006.
Avner, Rina. "The Dome of the Rock in light of the development of concentric Martyria in Jerusalem: Architecture and Architectural Iconography." Muqarnas, Volume 27. Brill, 2011. 31-50.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
194
views
The Origins of Islam - 7.1 Before the Dome of the Rock
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
In this video, we are briefly looking at the history of the Temple Mount before the Dome of the Rock. It may be surprising to some that not a single source mentions the Rock at the centre of the Temple platform before the 4th century AD.
#Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Temple #Mount #Jerusalem #domeoftherock #Dome #Rock #Judaism #templemount
Reference for this episode:
Grabar, Oleg. The Dome of the Rock. Harvard University Press, 2006.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
232
views
The Dome of the Rock: A Response to AJ Deus - 4 - Conclusion
This video hopefully marks the end to my A.J. Deus series. Initially, I wanted to combine the content of this video with my upcoming videos on the Dome of the Rock wherein I want to present my alternative hypothesis. But I have now decided that I want my videos to stand on their own and not refer to A.J. Deus. Therefore I have made this video wherein I present a conclusion to my series as well as some corrections and some new findings.
Unfortunately, upon editing the video, I have realised that the video quality is not great. I tried a new setting on my recording software and while the test recordings looked good, it didn't turn out so well with the actual session. There are unfortunately artefacts throughout the video.
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
161
views
1
comment
Snippet: Was the inscription inside the Dome of the Rock changed during the 19th century?
This is an excerpt of the full video wherein we go over A.J. Deus' argument that the Dome of the Rock was a late forgery. As it turns out, all of his core evidence turns into thin air upon close investigation.
Full video here: https://youtu.be/XKI-Yx3B7_0
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
76
views
Snippet: Was Jesus' grave moved from the Dome of the Rock to the Holy Sepulchre?
This is an excerpt of the full video wherein we go over A.J. Deus' argument that the Dome of the Rock was a late forgery. As it turns out, all of his core evidence turns into thin air upon close investigation.
Full video here: https://youtu.be/XKI-Yx3B7_0
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
71
views
2
comments
Snippet: Did the Dome of the Rock exist in 870 AD?
This is an excerpt of the full video wherein we go over A.J. Deus' argument regarding the layout of the Temple Mount in the year 870 AD. As it turns out, he couldn't be more wrong when he says that there was no Dome of the Rock and that instead there was a synagogue at the northern end of the platform.
Full video here: https://youtu.be/XKI-Yx3B7_0
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
61
views
The Dome of the Rock: A Response to AJ Deus - 3 - Written Sources
Finally, we're having a look at the many written sources which are brought up by A.J. Deus as evidence for his conjecture of a late Dome of the Rock. But what do they really say?
As it turns out, A.J. is misreading and misinterpreting most of his own sources. In many cases, they say the exact opposite of what A.J. claims they are saying.
By the end, nothing is left, his entire argument crumbles because none of his foundational claims can be supported, in fact, most of them can be refuted.
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
56
views
1
comment
Snippet: Were the depictions of the Dome of the Rock produced by eye witnesses?
This is an excerpt of the full video wherein we go over A.J. Deus' argument regarding the shape of the Dome of the Rock's drum. He claims that medieval depictions prove that the Dome of the Rock used to have an octagonal shape.
Full video here: https://youtu.be/Dcwehs06p2k
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
49
views
Snippet: Was the Dome of the Rock's drum octagonal?
This is an excerpt of the full video wherein we go over A.J. Deus' argument regarding the shape of the Dome of the Rock's drum. He claims that medieval depictions prove that the Dome of the Rock used to have an octagonal shape.
Full video here: https://youtu.be/Dcwehs06p2k
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
53
views
The Dome of the Rock: A Response to AJ Deus - 2 - Depictions of the Dome
In this video, we will go over A.J. Deus' argument regarding the shape of the Dome of the Rock's drum. He claims that medieval depictions prove that the Dome of the Rock used to have an octagonal shape.
However, when going through the evidence, it becomes clear that there is no reason to doubt that the Dome of the Rock was always round like it is today.
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
52
views
The Dome of the Rock: A Response to AJ Deus - 1 - Introduction
A.J. Deus' latest paper on the Dome of the Rock has caused some waves. In it, he argues for a young Dome of the Rock with a fake history. According to A.J., the inscriptions are late forgeries and the Dome in its current form has existed for less than 200 years.
Given how extensive the article is, I had to take quite some time to look into A.J. Deus' claims. As it turns out, none of his claims hold up to scrutiny. A.J. is asking some legitimate questions, but his answers are not warranted.
In this video, I will give a quick introduction into the claims made by A.J. Deus and we will look at an initial example for an error on A.J.'s part which showcases how he fails to correctly read his own sources, something that we will see again and again in later videos.
#islam #domeoftherock #jerusalem #al-malik #al-mamun #dome #rock #safa #ajdeus #fraud #christianity #judaism #arab
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
____________________
Here you can find A.J. Deus' paper:
https://www.academia.edu/69970087/THE_JEWISH_SERPENT_KING_IN_THE_DOME_OF_THE_ROCK_Primary_Evidence_Big_Daddy_of_Inscriptions_A_Colossal_Fraud_2022
57
views
Thomas the Presbyter - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 20
Thomas the Presbyter is believed to be one of the earliest non-Arab sources for the existence of Muhammad. But what does he really say and what can we learn from it?
#Islam #Quran #History #Education #Religion #Thomas #Presbyter #SIN #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
59
views
The Chronica Minora - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 19
Another document which is often used to support the Islamic narrative is the so called "Chronica Minora", also known as the Chronicle of Khuzestan. But what can we really learn from it?
#Islam #Quran #History #Education #Religion #Minora #Syriac #Chronicle #SIN #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Title music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
52
views
Sebeos' History of Heraclius - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 18
It is widely believed that the Armenian bishop Sebeos was the first to explicitly mention the Prophet Muhammad. In this episode, we will look at the text in question and its author.
#Islam #Quran #History #Education #Religion #Sebeos #Heraclius #Muhammad #SIN #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Title music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
64
views
The Doctrina Jacobi - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 17
When it comes to evidence for the existence of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, the number one document which people refer to is the Doctrina Jacobi. But what does it really say? As we will find out, it's far being a credible support of the Islamic narrative.
#Islam #Quran #History #Education #Religion #Jacobi #Doctrina #SIN #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Title music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
53
views
Sophronius' Christmas Sermon - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 16
Starting with this episode, we will be looking at sources from outside the Islamic world which are typically used to support the Islamic narrative.
In this episode, we're starting off with Sophronius' Christmas sermon which is often believed to confirm the idea of an Islamic invasion in Syria and Palestine around the year 634 AD which is when the sermon was held. We will see that Sophronius does not mention an invasion, nor sieges or captured cities.
#Islam #Quran #History #Education #Religion #Sophronius #SIN #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Title music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
56
views
Radiocarbon Dating Manuscripts - 3 Minute Quran Study: Episode 15
We often hear about ancient manuscripts that have been given a rough date of origin using radiocarbon dating. But how precise are our dating methods? In this video, we'll find out that while radiocarbon dating is a brilliant tool, it may not suit the challenge of dating parchment.
#Dating #Radiocarbon #Parchment #Manuscript #Physics #C14 #Quran #Islam #History #Education #Religion #Science #3mqs
____________________
The "3 Minute Quran Study" series is intended to slice the complex historical critical analysis of the Quran into bite-sized chunks that are easy to understand. In my upcoming book, I will explore all these topics in more detail. Followers on Patreon will get regular updates on my progress with this enormous endeavour.
Title music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
59
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.6 The Codex Parisino-Petropolitanus II
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
By looking at the corrections made by the scribe who wrote one of the oldest Quranic manuscripts, we can reconstruct the original contents of the Quran.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran #Ishaq #Zayd #Zaynab #Seal
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Powers, David S. Muhammad is not the Father of Any of Your Men. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
67
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.5 The Codex Parisino-Petropolitanus I
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
By looking at the corrections made by the scribe who wrote one of the oldest Quranic manuscripts, we can reconstruct the original contents of the Quran.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran #Ishaq #Zayd #Zaynab #Seal
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Powers, David S. Muhammad is not the Father of Any of Your Men. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
42
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.4 Cascading Changes
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
Establishing Muhammad as the seal of the prophets required multiple changes to th Quran, each change necessitating further updates to the text. Here, we are looking at these changes.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran #Ishaq #Zayd #Zaynab #Seal
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Ibn Ishaq. "The Life of Muhammad. Translated by A. Guillaume." (1955).
Powers, David S. Muhammad is not the Father of Any of Your Men. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011.
Reynolds, Gabriel Said. The Emergence of Islam: Classical traditions in contemporary perspective. Fortress Press, 2012.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
31
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.3 Zayd & The Seal of the Prophets
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
For Muhammad to become the seal of the prophets, it was necessary to establish that he did not have any male heirs. Zayd played an important role in that process.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran #Ishaq #Zayd #Zaynab #Seal
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Ibn Ishaq. "The Life of Muhammad. Translated by A. Guillaume." (1955).
Powers, David S. Muhammad is not the Father of Any of Your Men. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011.
Reynolds, Gabriel Said. The Emergence of Islam: Classical traditions in contemporary perspective. Fortress Press, 2012.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
22
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.2 The Sira-Quran Feedback
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
While the life of Muhammad was constructed in order to explain the Quran, analysis of the commentaries shows how he Sira itself was later turned into Quranic passages. In this video, we are looking at th evidence.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran #Ishaq
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Ibn Ishaq. "The Life of Muhammad. Translated by A. Guillaume." (1955).
Reynolds, Gabriel Said. The Emergence of Islam: Classical traditions in contemporary perspective. Fortress Press, 2012.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
38
views
The Origins of Islam - 6.1 The Sira as Context for the Quran
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
The Quran is typically understood in the light of the life of Muhammad. However, his turns out to be a circular approach as the biography of Muhammad was constructed in order to explain the Quran. We therefor have to look at it in reverse. The biography of Muhammad has to be understood in the light of the Quran.
#Quran #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arab #Sira #Sunna #Sunnah #Tafsir #Muhammad #Biography #Koran
References for this episode:
Dequin, Raymond "Der frühe abbasidische Koran"'. In: Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion VI: Vom umayadischen Christentum zum abbasidischen Islam. Inârah Vol. 10. 2021,
pp. 146–233.
Reynolds, Gabriel Said. The Emergence of Islam: Classical traditions in contemporary perspective. Fortress Press, 2012.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
31
views
A 13th Century Pespective on Islam - The Travels of Riccoldo da Monte di Croce
In this video, we want to look at the 13th century echos of the origins of Islam while following in the footsteps of the Dominican friar Riccoldo da Monte di Croce.
#islam #dominican #pilgrimage #nestorian #jacobite #miaphysite #monophysite #church #east #friar #mongol #tartar #jerualem #acre #acco #baghdad
Music by Darren Curtis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
25
views
The Origins of Islam - 5.2 The Islamisation of Spain: Al-Andalus
REFERENCES IN THE DESCRIPTION BELOW
After the Berbers and and Arabs took over Spain, we don't see evidence of a new religion for more than a century. Instead all the evidence points to an adoptionist christology slowly spreading in al-Andalus before this anti-Trinitarian Christian sect tipped over into the new religion of Islam.
In this video, we ill also look at the myth of the utopia of al-Andalus and how it has little to do with reality.
#Spain #Islam #Origin #History #Education #Religion #Arabic #Christian #Berber #Trinity #Trinitarian #Arian #Hispania #Iberia #Portugal #Arab #Umayyad #Andalus
References for this episode:
Al-Muqqadasî, Description de l’occident musulman, Algier 1950
Baudissin, Wolf Wilhelm Graf von. Eulogius und Alvar. Ein Abschnitt spanischer Kirchengeschichte aus der Zeit der Maurenherrschaft, Leipzig 1872
Casiri, Miguel. Bibliotheca arabico-hispana Escurialensis sive librorum omnium mss quos arabice ab auctoribus magnam partem arabo-hispanis compositos bibliotheca coenobii Escuralensis complectitur recensio et explanatio, 2 t., Madrid 1760-1770
Crónica mozárabe de 754. Ed. crÃtica y traducción por José Eduardo Lopez Pereira, Zaragoza 1980
Continuatio Byzantia Arabica A. DCCXLI, in: Theodorus Mommsen, MGH, Auct. Antiq. Tomus XI. Chronicorum minorum sec. IV, V, VI, VII, vol. II, Berlin 1894
DÃaz y DÃaz, Manuel C. "La cultura de la España visigótica del siglo VII", in: Caratteri del secolo VII in Occidente. Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull’Alto Medioevo, T. II, Spoleto 1958
Fanjul, Serafin. Al-Andalus contra España. La forja del mito, Madrid 2000.
Fontaine, Jean. Isidore de Séville et la culture classique dans l’Espagne wisigothique, 2 Bde. Paris 1959
Franke, Franz Richard. Die freiwilligen Märtyrer von Cordova und das Verhältnis der Mozaraber zum Islam (nach den Schriften des Speraindeo, Eulogius und Alvar), Münster 1968
Helfferich, Adolf. Der westgothische Arianismus und die spanische Ketzergeschichte, Berlin 1860,
História de los jueces de Córdoba por Aljoxani, Texto árabe y traducción española por Julián Ribera, Madrid 1914
Machmuâ, Ajbar. Crónica arábiga del siglo XI, dada á luz por primera vez, traducida y anotada por Don Emilio Lafuente y Alcántara, Madrid 1967
Makki, Mahmud. "Egipto y los origenes de la historiografia árabe-española", in: Instituto de Estudios islámicos en Madrid, Revista, 5, Nr. 1/2, 1957, 157-148
Olagüe, Ignacio. La revolución islámica en Occidente, Guadarrama 1974
Palacios, Miguel AsÃn. Aben Musarra y su escuela, Madrid 1914
Ridao, José Maria. Contra la Historia, Barcelona 2000.
Sánchez-Albornoz y Menduina, Claudio. El „Ajbar Maymua“. Cuestiones historiográficas que suscita, Buenos Aires 1944
Thomas, Johannes. "Frühe spanische Zeugnisse zum Islam: Vorschläge für eine differenzierte Betrachtung der Konflikte und der religiösen Gemeinsamkeiten zwischen dem Osten und dem Westen des arabischen Reiches." Schlaglichter (2008): 93-186.
____________________
The "Origin of Islam" series is intended to provide a big-picture look at how Islam started, where it came from, how it evolved and how we ended up with the religion we know of today. I'm introducing the historical critical method as it's applied to the Quran and paint a new narrative based on primary evidence and linguistic analysis.
____________________
If you like my content and would like me to be able to continue producing more, you can support me in the following ways:
Become a Patron and get access to some exclusive content: https://www.patreon.com/thomasalexander
Donate via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=YSYV837J48JVA
Donate Bitcoin: 36AcDS46SGX23xSDQWJQi9C4xtGaqevGba
Donate ETH or ERC20 Tokens: 0x466b19D59D0Ad527a27871001e18283fA6F3D2fd
66
views
1
comment