Defenses to the Tort of Bad Faith
The Genuine Dispute Doctrine
Insurers in states where the tort of bad faith exists deny fraudulent insurance claims with fear and trembling. The specter of punitive damages has worked to make multi-millionaires of many insurance criminals who convince insurers to settle rather than take a chance on trial. Insurers pay claims they believe they do not owe because they are fearful—regardless of the merits of their position—of being assessed punitive damages in a bad faith action.
The fear is not well placed if the suspected fraudulent claim or non-covered loss is denied based upon a fair and thorough investigation, an intelligent review of the facts as they relate to the policy wording, and a reasonable application of the law of the jurisdiction. If, after a fair and thorough investigation, an insurer believes that a fraud is being attempted or that the loss is not covered by the policy wording, the dispute between the insurer and the insured is one of fact not tort and the insured is limited to recovery of contract damages.
If the insurer has done its work properly before denying a claim it should never be held liable for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Tort and punitive damages allegations should be eliminated as a matter of law.
In Guebara v. Allstate Insurance Co., 237 F. 3d 987 (9th Cir. 2001), Allstate believed, from its investigation that Guebara had attempted fraud. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal held:
"The genuine dispute in this case was not purely factual. The genuine dispute as to the contents claims was based on factual evidence—three expert opinions, inconsistent testimony by Guebara and her witnesses, and desperate financial circumstances. The genuine dispute as to the structure claim, however, was based on the fraud language in the policy and on an unsettled issue in California insurance law."
-
11:17
Barry Zalma, Inc. on Insurance Law
1 year agoDenial of Defense Not Bad Faith
54 -
17:58
Barry Zalma, Inc. on Insurance Law
3 years agoAdvice of Counsel as a Defense to the Tort of Bad Faith
307 -
0:15
AttorneysMedia
2 years agoWhat Is Bad Faith In Regards To The Actions Of An Insurance Company ?
14 -
10:30
Attorneys4Freedom
1 year agoUnderstand Your Legal Defense Policy
9 -
9:56
ArmedAttorneys
4 months ago $0.05 earnedCan a Thief Claim Self-Defense?
3051 -
0:57
The Last Capitalist in Chicago
11 months agoWhat happens if you get sued for more than your policy limit?
28 -
0:16
AttorneysMedia
2 years agoWhat Is The Potential Outcome Of A Bad Faith Claim Against An Insurance Company ?
2 -
4:12
St. Louis Injury Law Experts
1 year agoWhat are Depositions and How are They Used in Litigating Cases
63 -
19:33
Ammon Bundy
10 months ago $0.03 earned4 Reasons I Have Not Defended Myself in the Court
1921 -
10:29
ArmedAttorneys
11 months agoCrime DOES Pay: DeSantis Law Won't Stop the Bad Guys from Suing Self-Defenders
1251