Why Hate Speech Laws Backfire
Here's a brutal irony about regulating hate speech: Such laws often end up hurting the very people they are supposed to protect.
That's one of the central lessons in Jacob Mchangama's important new book, Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media. Mchangama heads up the Danish think tank Justitia. He's worried about a proposal that would make hate speech a crime under European Union (EU) law and give bureaucrats in Brussels sweeping powers to prosecute people spewing venom at religious and ethnic minorities, members of the LGBT+ community, women, and others.
Europe's history with such laws argues against them. In the 1920s, Germany's Weimar Republic strictly regulated the press and invoked emergency powers to crack down on Nazi speech. It censored and prosecuted the editor of the anti-Semitic Nazi paper Der Stürmer, Julius Streicher, who used his trial as a platform for spreading his views and his imprisonment as a way of turning himself into a martyr and his cause into a crusade. When the Nazis took power in the early '30s, Mchangama stresses, they expanded existing laws and precedents to shut down dissent and freedom of assembly.
Contemporary scholarship suggests that there can be a "backlash effect" when governments shut down speech, leading otherwise moderate people to embrace fringe beliefs. Mchangama points to a 2017 study published in the European Journal of Political Research that concluded extremism in Western Europe was fueled in part by "extensive public repression of radical right actors and opinions."
In 1965, the United Kingdom passed a law banning "incitement to racial hatred," but one of the very first people prosecuted under it was a black Briton who called whites "vicious and nasty people" in a speech. More recently, Mchangama notes that radical feminists in England "have been charged with offending LGBT+ people because they insist there are biological differences between the sexes. In France, 'an LGBT+ rights organization was fined for calling an opponent of same-sex marriage a 'homophobe.'"
"Once the principle of free speech is abandoned," warns Mchangama, "any minority can end up being targeted rather than protected by laws against hatred and offense."
That's what happened in Canada in the 1990s after the Supreme Court there ruled that words and images that "degrade" women should be banned. The decision was based in part on the legal theories of feminist author Andrea Dworkin, whose books on why pornography should be banned were briefly seized by Canadian customs agents under the laws she helped to inspire.
First Amendment rights are still popular in the United States, with 91 percent of us in a recent survey agreeing that "protecting free speech is an important part of American democracy." But 60 percent of us also said that the government should prohibit people from sharing a racist or bigoted idea.
Hearing hateful words and ideas outrages and discomforts most of us, but Mchangama's history of free speech underscores that state suppression can grant those words and ideas more power and influence. And that the best antidote to hate in a free and open society is not to hide from it but to openly—and persuasively—confront it.
Listen to my Reason Interview podcast with Jacob Mchangama at https://reason.com/podcast/2022/02/16/jacob-mchangama-how-hate-speech-laws-punish-minorities/.
Written by Nick Gillespie. Edited by Regan Taylor.
-
36:25
ReasonTV
1 month agoNew documentary shows why college students are rejecting wokeness | The Reason Interview
1.77K3 -
22:39
Misha Petrov
19 hours agoI Took The “Am I Fatphobic?” Quiz
42.7K27 -
6:50
The Gun Collective
1 day agoTop things WRONG with this gun...
41.2K12 -
12:51
Liam Reid
15 hours ago9-Year-Old 250 2 Stroke vs Modern 4 Stroke!
58.1K19 -
7:20
Adam Does Movies
18 hours agoBlink Twice Movie Review - A Thrilling Start For Zoë Kravitz
48.3K11 -
1:37:26
Game On!
16 hours ago $6.41 earnedCollege Football 2024 Has ARRIVED!
57.3K4 -
26:27
barstoolsports
1 day agoCo-Workers Survive a Week Together At Summer Camp
80.2K5 -
44:10
TampaAerialMedia
9 hours agoPigeon Forge 2024 Travel Guide
48.4K7 -
38:28
Popcorn In Bed
1 day agoROCKY IV (1985) | FIRST TIME WATCHING | MOVIE REACTION
45.4K4 -
6:46
Tactical Advisor
11 hours agoSniper Testing Insane Computer Monitor Shot
37.9K5