Lemon Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

Show more

You are Here: Masala Herb » Cookies » Lemon Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

Lemon Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

Published: Dec 4, 2019 · Modified: Aug 12, 2021 by Helene Dsouza

23784SHARES

Helene Dsouza

Melt in the mouth lemon thumbprint cookies filled with raspberry jam.

 Total Time: 45 minutes

4.74 from 23 votes

 Jump to Recipe



Melt in the mouth Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies with lemon flavor are our favorite cookies right now.

They are easily made and we get to use up my beautiful raspberry jam.



Jump to:

What are Thumbprint Cookies?

How to make it?

Storing

Variations

FAQs

Similiar Cookie Recipes

📖 Recipe

💬 Comments

What are Thumbprint Cookies?

Thumbprint cookies are called that way because you press into a ball of raw cookie dough with your thumb to create a crater.

The cookies are then filled with jelly or jam and baked.

They originated in Sweden where they are called Hallongrottor, which means Raspberry Cave.

The classic cookies are flavored with vanilla and filled with raspberry jam.

Thumbprint cookies are also super popular in neighboring Scandinavian countries, in Germany, Austria, Italy, and Alsace (France).

We call them Kulleraugen (translated running eyes) in German and my grandmother would make them every year again in Austria before Christmas.

Original raspberry thumbprint cookies are kind of shortbread cookies. They call Mör or Mördeg in Swedish and Mürbteig in German.

I flavor mine with lemon zest or lemon extract instead of vanilla because I think raspberry and lemon is the ultimate flavor combination.



How to make it?

You will rejoice because these are the easiest cookies to make out there.

No rolling out, no shaping and breaking, just pure Christmas baking fun!

This is a preview on how to make your own batch of raspberry thumbprint cookies from scratch this season.

Find the complete Recipe with ingredients, detailed instructions, and video in the recipe card at the bottom of the post.

Step 1

Add the flour, powdered sugar and salt to a mixing bowl and combine.

Make a well in the center and add in the lemon extract, egg yolk, and butter.



Step 2

Crumble wet ingredients into dry ingredients.

Combine to a smooth dough and wrap into cling film.

Place into the fridge to cool.



Step 3

Unwrap cold hardened dough and cut into pieces.

Roll each piece into a small ball and place on a baking sheet.



Step 4

Make a hole with your thumb into each ball and fill it with jelly.

Bake your cookies.





Storing

Keep the cookies out to cool right after baking.

Line a tin box with parchment paper and place your cookies carefully into the box over each other.

Place another sheet of parchment paper fitting over the cookies and close with the lids.

Store in a cool and dry place.

If your cookies are getting too dry (this happens in a dry and cold environment) then place the peel of an apple over the parchment paper.

If you live in a tropically hot and humid climate, store your cookies in an airtight container to prevent them from getting soggy and spoiled.



Variations

Besides Lemon flavored Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies, you can make your own by pepping up your flavor options.

Classic thumbprint cookies are flavored with vanilla extract instead of lemon.

Switch the raspberry jelly with another jelly over your choices, such as Red Currant Jelly or even Lingonberry Jam.

You can use other jellies too such as Apple Jelly but I recommend a colorful bright red or pink jelly because your cookies will look all the better.

Or how about you flavor your dough to your liking by adding one of the following ingredients:

Orange Zest or Orange extract

Cardamom Spice Powder

Bitter Almond Extract

You can also switch the sugar with a special brown sugar or sugar cane sugar.



FAQs

Can I freeze the dough?

Yes, you can freeze your thumbprint cookie dough once you have prepared a smooth dough. Wrap it into cling film and store in the freezer until you intend to use it. Allow thawing completely before using it.

Why did my cookies crack before baking?

When pressing into the ball with your thumb, the cookies can crack a bit at the edges (which is normal). To reduce cracking, work with the dough in room temperature (leave it out after cooling for 10-15 minutes) and the more gently you press in with your thumb the fewer cracks will appear.

Why did my thumbprint cookies spread?

Thumbprint cookies always spread a bit and that's normal. Yet, there is an amount of normal spreading that occurs, too much ain't good. The cookies are made of butter and sugar and when hot these ingredients get soft. To avoid too much spreading of your cookies, always cool dough first and then shape and bake at the correct temperature at 350 Fahrenheit/ 180 Celsius.

Similiar Cookie Recipes

Sugar Cookies

Linzer Cookies

Vanillekipferl

Jam-filled Sandwich Cookies by natashaskitchen.com