5 Indiana Cold Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #466

Step into the chilling world of unresolved mysteries with "5 True Crime Cases in Indiana." These five haunting stories remain clouded in uncertainty, leaving families and communities yearning for answers and justice.

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories in Indiana
🔹 Brookley Chantille Louks — A 19-year-old on the cusp of a fresh start vanishes after stopping by a Greenwood apartment where a puzzling burglary had just occurred. A witness, a blue Corsica, and a car found miles away set the stage for a case that still stings.
🔹 Ja’Niyah McMichael — A 13-year-old Gary girl disappears after a late-night argument. Rumors, online finger-pointing, and gang tensions muddy the search as the FBI joins a case where safety and truth both feel scarce.
🔹 Nancy Kay Lyons — Beloved church worker and lifelong caregiver disappears on a short drive home from Walmart. A flat tire, a running car on a rural road, and months of silence end with a heartbreaking discovery far from Carthage.
🔹 Raymond Lee “Raylee” Hunley Jr. — After a pickup game at the Portland armory, a young Guardsman’s car is found still running with new clothes inside—and no sign of him. Decades later, a family revelation and missing records deepen the mystery.
🔹 Ronli Kay Ratliff — A Mooresville woman helping at her family’s body shop is found murdered after a suspicious house fire. Conflicting stories, drug-world fear, and a clock frozen at 3:30 a.m. keep one of Indiana’s darkest cases unsolved.

🔍 Uncover the Details:
Explore the timelines, key evidence, and unanswered questions surrounding these gripping cases. Could you hold the missing piece of the puzzle? Share your theories in the comments and join the conversation!

💡 Stay Engaged:
👉 Subscribe for weekly true crime videos: https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1
👉 Explore our unsolved cases playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEgVw7wlWtzqWER3bquZo95HyfENaFeU_
👉 Have a case suggestion? Email us: [email protected]

Support the Channel:
👉 Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories
☕ Support the channel on Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

Donations:
👉 PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=XENJPDT5MREMC
👉 Venmo: www.venmo.com/u/southerngirlcrimestories

📚 Sources:
https://controlc.com/abfab5ee

📺 YouTube Chapters
🔹 00:00 – Introduction: 5 Chilling True Crime Stories in Indiana
🔹 00:12 – Brookley Chantille Louks (Greenwood, 2002)
🔹 08:33 – Ja’Niyah McMichael (Gary, 2024)
🔹 13:12 – Nancy Kay Lyons (Carthage/Rush County, 2002)
🔹 18:06 – Raymond Lee “Raylee” Hunley Jr. (Portland, 1982)
🔹 21:04 – Ronli Kay Ratliff (Mooresville, 2004)

#truecrimediscussion #UnsolvedCases #CrimeStories #coldcases #JusticeForVictims #TrueCrimeCommunity #Indiana