Episode 3210: Silence: Guarding the Tongue in a Noisy Age

www.catholic-reboot.com
Nightly Zoom Coordinates for Rosary:
Meeting ID: 865 8978 0399
Passcode: Wjjv4960!
Speak Lord for your Servant is Listening
Book Recommendation of the Day
“Passio Sancti Proti et Hyacinthi martyrum” (BHL 2667) This is the early Passion (hagiographic act) about the lives and martyrdom of Protus and Hyacinth. The work in Latin dates from around the late 5th century (between 450–499).
This Latin Passion was translated into Greek, Syriac, Armenian, etc., in later centuries.
“The Desert Fathers on Silence: Guarding the Tongue in a Noisy Age”
Why Silence Matters
From the beginning, the Church has taught that the tongue is a small member with great power. St. James says bluntly: “If anyone does not stumble in what he says, he is a perfect man” (James 3:2).
The Desert Fathers took this teaching seriously. They saw that idle speech, gossip, and rash words not only damage communities, but also suffocate the interior life of prayer. Silence was not emptiness for them; it was a school of holiness, a furnace where humility and recollection were forged.
In our age of constant noise phones buzzing, news channels blaring, social media overflowing their message is more urgent than ever.
Segment1: What the Desert Fathers Said About Speech
The Desert Fathers lived in silence because they understood something we often forget: words have tremendous spiritual weight. They knew that the tongue, while small, can set the entire course of life ablaze, as St. James teaches: “The tongue is a fire… It defiles the whole body, setting on fire the cycle of nature, and itself set on fire by hell.” (James 3:6).
They fled into the desert not only to avoid sin in action, but to master sin in speech. Their sayings on silence are not random pious thoughts, but hard-won lessons forged in solitude, prayer, and constant battle with demons.
Abba Arsenius: The Wisdom of Silence
Abba Arsenius had been a tutor to the sons of the Roman Emperor. He was surrounded by courtly eloquence, rhetoric, and the flattery of high society. Yet when he entered the desert, his prayer was simple:

“O Lord, teach me to be silent.”
Why would a man who had spent his life among words beg God for silence? Because Arsenius realized that words can deceive they can puff up the ego, scatter the mind, and obscure God’s voice.
He later admitted:
“I have often repented of speaking, but never of being silent.”
This is not a condemnation of speech itself, but a recognition that silence guards the soul. Speech is often regretted because it reveals pride, anger, or carelessness. Silence, however, gives space for reflection, repentance, and humility.
Arsenius shows us that the path to holiness is not eloquence, but restraint.
Abba Poemen: The Silence of the Heart
Abba Poemen, one of the most quoted of the Desert Fathers, gave a deeper insight:
“A man may seem to be silent, but if his heart is condemning others, he is babbling ceaselessly. True silence is of the heart.”
This distinction is crucial. Silence is not simply the absence of words. A monk might keep his lips closed yet spend the whole day internally judging others, replaying conversations, or nourishing resentment. That is not silence; it is interior noise.
True silence means disciplining the heart as well as the tongue. It means cutting off not just gossip in the mouth, but judgment in the mind. It is silence filled with charity and attentiveness to God.
Abba Agathon: The Danger of Careless Words
Abba Agathon went even further in his warning:
“A man who is angry, even if he raises the dead, is not acceptable to God. So too the man who speaks carelessly.”
Here the seriousness is striking. Even miracles are worthless if the soul is enslaved to anger and careless speech. Agathon equates uncontrolled words with spiritual death.
This tells us that holiness is not proven by spectacular deeds but by the humility of the tongue. Miracles may impress men, but God looks at the charity or the lack of it in our words.
Silence as Fasting of the Tongue
The Desert Fathers did not advocate muteness. They spoke when charity or necessity required it. But they viewed silence as a discipline, a kind of fasting.
Just as fasting from food purifies the body and makes space for prayer, fasting from words purifies the soul and opens the heart to God. Words were to be measured like precious coins used sparingly, carefully, and for good.
This is why the Fathers spoke rarely and briefly. They recognized that idle words dissipate the soul, scattering attention outward, while silence gathers the heart inward, recollected in God.
Silence as Spiritual Warfare
For the Desert Fathers, silence was not passive but active. It was a weapon of spiritual warfare.
• It guarded the heart from pride, because speech so easily slips into boasting.
• It cut off gossip before it could spread and destroy community.
• It created space for listening to God, since His voice is most often heard in quiet.
Silence for them was not emptiness. It was filled with prayer, vigilance, and the presence of God.
Traditional Catholic Perspective
From a traditional Catholic lens, the Fathers’ teaching on speech resonates deeply with our heritage:
• The Liturgical Silence of the Mass: In the Traditional Latin Mass, many prayers are said quietly, teaching us that not all words are for human ears, but for God alone.
• The Example of St. Joseph: The foster father of Jesus speaks no recorded word in Scripture. His silence was not weakness, but strength, humility, and deep faith.
• The Warnings of Christ: Our Lord Himself declared: “I tell you, on the day of judgment men will render account for every careless word they utter.” (Matthew 12:36).

This shows that the Desert Fathers were not extreme in their caution. They were living out the very words of Christ in the most radical and faithful way possible.
Closing Thought for Segment 1
The Desert Fathers remind us that holiness is not measured by eloquence, clever arguments, or endless speech, but by the purity and discipline of the tongue.
• Abba Arsenius teaches us to love silence.
• Abba Poemen teaches us that true silence begins in the heart.
• Abba Agathon teaches us that careless words can nullify even great deeds.
Their wisdom calls us to see silence not as absence, but as presence: the presence of humility, charity, and God Himself.
Segment 2: Why Idle Speech is More Dangerous Today
The Desert Fathers fought against gossip and careless words in small desert monasteries. But today, the battlefield is no longer confined to a few huts in the Egyptian wilderness it has expanded into the whole world. Idle speech has never been more frequent, more rapid, or more destructive than it is in our age.
The Culture of Constant Noise
In the ancient desert, silence was cultivated like a precious jewel. Today, noise is everywhere and it is constant. Social media, streaming television, podcasts, texting, and nonstop news have made words cheap and endless.
People feel compelled to comment on everything: politics, scandals, even sacred matters of the Church. To remain silent is seen not as wisdom, but as weakness or ignorance. Yet the Fathers knew that silence is not cowardice but strength for only in silence does the soul hear God.
The modern man is addicted to words, yet starving for truth. He cannot sit still, cannot endure quiet, because silence would confront him with his conscience and with God.
Gossip and Division
Idle speech does not remain harmless chatter. In our families, workplaces, and parishes, it corrodes unity. Gossip stirs resentment and suspicion, often leaving wounds that take years to heal.
The Desert Fathers would say: every uncharitable word is a dagger in the Mystical Body of Christ. Today, those daggers multiply rapidly because of how quickly gossip spreads. A whispered criticism once traveled only through a small community; now it spreads through group chats, parish emails, or online forums, destroying reputations in hours.
Division in families, friendships, and even entire parishes often begins with nothing more than idle talk. This is why the Fathers placed such gravity on speech for words, once released, cannot be recalled.
Online Rash Judgment
The internet has magnified rash judgment in ways the Fathers could not have imagined. One careless comment, posted in anger or frustration, can reach thousands or even millions within moments.
Christ warned: “I tell you, on the day of judgment men will render account for every careless word they utter.” (Matthew 12:36). That warning is terrifying enough when we think of spoken words; how much more when multiplied through tweets, blogs, and comment sections that remain online for years?
The digital world tempts us to pronounce judgments quickly and harshly, often with no full knowledge of facts. The Fathers remind us that true silence of the heart requires not only refraining from speaking, but from condemning. Without that discipline, the internet becomes a furnace of uncharitable speech.
Loss of Recollection
Idle chatter also scatters the soul. Constant talk, whether online or in person, leaves no room for prayer. Our minds become restless, distracted, and incapable of recollection.
The Desert Fathers taught that silence preserves the memory of God. But in our time, silence is feared. Many avoid it by keeping headphones in their ears, the television always on, or social media constantly refreshed. Yet this endless noise prevents us from hearing the still, small voice of God.
The Fathers would say that modern chatter is not just idle it is dangerous. It creates a spiritual deafness, where God’s call is drowned out by the clamor of the world.
Conclusion: Why More Destructive Today
Idle speech has always been a threat to the soul. But today, its scope has widened:
• Words are endless — cheapened by mass communication.
• Gossip spreads faster — tearing apart parishes and families.
• Rash judgment multiplies — reaching millions with a single post.
• Silence is feared — leaving little room for recollection and prayer.
For these reasons, the danger is greater in our age than in the deserts of Egypt. The Fathers teach us that guarding the tongue is guarding the heart. And in our time, this discipline is not optional it is essential for salvation.
Segment 3: Remedies from the Desert Tradition
The Desert Fathers never warned us about sins of the tongue without also offering remedies. They were not content to simply say, “Avoid idle speech.” They gave us practical wisdom to tame the tongue, sanctify our words, and embrace the silence where God is found. These remedies remain as necessary in our age as in theirs.
Love of Silence
Abba Isaiah once said: “When you love silence, you will draw near to God, and in your silence He will draw near to you.”
Silence must be seen not as emptiness, but as fullness. It is not the absence of noise, but the presence of God. In silence, the heart becomes attentive — we hear Him in prayer, in the reading of Scripture, and in the quiet voice of conscience.
In our noisy world, cultivating silence may feel unnatural. Yet the Fathers remind us: silence is the atmosphere of heaven. The angels veil their faces before God in quiet adoration. To love silence is to train the soul for eternity.
2. Guarding the Tongue
The Fathers knew that holiness begins with discipline of speech. Their rule was simple:
• Speak only when necessary.
• Speak only words of charity.
• Let words be brief, humble, and seasoned with prayer.
This was later codified by St. Benedict in his Rule: “If you have something to ask, do so humbly and with all quietness.” (Rule of St. Benedict, Ch. 6).
The idea is not to eliminate all words, but to weigh them carefully. Every sentence becomes an offering to God. Every restraint becomes an act of penance. In this way, even speech becomes a path to sanctity.
Examination of Words
The Desert Fathers gave us a threefold examination before speaking:
1. Is it true? – Idle speech often thrives on exaggeration, rumor, or falsehood. Truth must be the foundation of every word.
2. Is it necessary? – Many words add nothing to charity or wisdom. They scatter the soul and feed vanity. If unnecessary, let them be left unsaid.
3. Is it charitable? – Even truth, if spoken harshly, can wound. Words must be spoken with love, or not at all.
If a word does not pass these three tests, it belongs in silence.

Scripture as a Guard
The Fathers armed themselves with Sacred Scripture to guard their lips. One of their favorite verses was from the Psalms:
“Set a guard, O Lord, over my mouth; keep watch over the door of my lips.” (Psalm 140:3).
Prayed daily, this verse becomes a shield. It reminds us that we cannot tame the tongue by human effort alone. Grace is required. The Fathers prayed constantly for God to restrain their words, just as He bridled the prophets and guided the Apostles.
Practical Ascesis
Finally, the Fathers were men of practice, not theory. They proposed ascetical exercises — small disciplines to train the soul:
• Limit idle talk during the day. Make deliberate choices to let silence reign where chatter would normally spill out.
• Dedicate time for silence at home. Turn off background noise, avoid filling every moment with words, and create a space of recollection. Even a brief daily period of holy silence can reorient the heart.
• Confess sins of gossip and rash judgment. The Fathers saw these as grave wounds to the soul and to the community. Bringing them to confession invites grace to heal the tongue and strengthen the will.
These ascetical practices remind us that discipline of speech is not simply about restraint — it is about sanctification. By taming the tongue, we become more conformed to Christ, the Word made Flesh, who Himself was silent before His accusers.
Conclusion
The Desert Fathers did not despise words, but they revered them. They knew that words can build up or tear down, bless or curse, sanctify or condemn. Their remedies love of silence, guarding the tongue, examining speech, praying with Scripture, and ascetical discipline remain timeless guides.
In a world where words are cheap and silence is feared, these remedies are more urgent than ever. By practicing them, we imitate Christ, who taught us that “out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks” (Matthew 12:34). If we guard our words, we guard our hearts — and in doing so, we draw nearer to God.
Segment 4: Traditional Catholic Applications Today
From a traditional Catholic perspective, silence is woven into our liturgy and spirituality.
• The Traditional Latin Mass emphasizes sacred silence. The priest prays many prayers quietly, teaching us that not all words are meant to be heard by men, but by God alone.
• The Rosary disciplines our speech, filling it with repeated prayer instead of idle words.
• Devotion to St. Joseph reminds us of the holiness of silence, since not a single word of his is recorded in Scripture.
Practical steps for Catholics today:
• Build “silence fasts” into your week — periods when you deliberately avoid unnecessary conversation or media.
• Replace idle talk with ejaculatory prayers: “Jesus, Mary, Joseph, I love you, save souls.”
• Foster silence in your home: turn off the TV during meals, pray together instead of filling every moment with chatter.
Silence is not withdrawal. It is a positive act of love for God, a way of tuning our hearts to eternity.
Conclusion: Silence as the Path to God
The Desert Fathers remind us that silence is not emptiness it is fullness. It is the presence of God filling the soul uncluttered by noise.
Abba Poemen said:
“Silence is not simply keeping still, but listening to God.”
In a world drunk on words, gossip, and noise, Catholics are called to be witnesses of recollection and holy silence. If we learn to guard our tongues and sanctify our speech, we will not only avoid sin, but open our hearts to the still, small voice of God.
Let us strive to be known not for many words, but for words seasoned with grace and above all, for the holy silence that allows God to reign in us.
Epistle – Hebrews 10:32–38
"Call to mind the former days, wherein, being illuminated, you endured a great fight of afflictions. And on the one hand indeed, by reproaches and tribulations, you were made a gazing stock; and on the other, made companions of them that were used in such sort. For you both had compassion on those who were in bands, and took with joy the being stripped of your own goods, knowing that you had a better and lasting substance. Do not therefore lose your confidence, which hath a great reward. For patience is necessary for you; that, doing the will of God, you may receive the promise... But my just man liveth by faith."
Reflection on the Epistle
The Apostle to the Hebrews reminds Christians to “call to mind the former days”—to remember how the first converts endured persecution with joy, knowing they had heaven as their true inheritance.
From a traditional Catholic perspective, this Epistle is a reminder that we must live with eternity in view. The modern Church often avoids speaking of sacrifice, penance, and persecution, preferring instead a comfortable faith. But St. Paul tells us: patience is necessary. Fidelity to God requires endurance, and only those who persevere to the end will receive the promise.
Sts. Protus and Hyacinth lived this Epistle. They lost everything family, possessions, even their lives but gained Christ. Their example challenges us: Are we willing to endure ridicule, exclusion, or loss for the sake of fidelity to the truth of the faith?
Gospel – Luke 12:1–8
"Beware ye of the leaven of the Pharisees, which is hypocrisy. For there is nothing covered, that shall not be revealed... And I say to you, my friends: Be not afraid of them who kill the body, and after that have no more that they can do. But I will show you whom you shall fear: fear ye him, who after he hath killed, hath power to cast into hell. Yea, I say to you, fear him. Are not five sparrows sold for two farthings, and not one of them is forgotten before God? Yea, the very hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not therefore: you are of more value than many sparrows. And I say to you: Whosoever shall confess me before men, him shall the Son of man also confess before the angels of God."

Reflection on the Gospel
Here Christ gives two commands:
1. Do not fear men. The worst they can do is kill the body.
2. Fear God. He alone judges the soul for eternity.
This is not a call to live in terror, but to live in holy fear, in reverence for God’s justice and love. Christ assures us of His providence every sparrow is known, every hair of our head is numbered. Yet He also demands courage: “Whosoever shall confess me before men, him will I confess before the angels of God.”
This Gospel is the very essence of martyrdom. The martyrs confessed Christ before men; now Christ confesses them in heaven. In our own lives, while martyrdom may not be demanded of us, public fidelity will. Do we confess Christ in our words, in our conduct, in our adherence to Catholic Tradition? Or do we remain silent, fearing ridicule or loss?
Sts. Protus and Hyacinth remind us that silence in the face of error is not an option. Fidelity requires confession, no matter the cost.

Feast of Sts. Protus and Hyacinth
Sts. Protus and Hyacinth were brothers and early martyrs of the Roman Church, executed during the persecution under Emperor Valerian in the 3rd century. Their tombs were discovered in the Catacombs of Basilla, testifying to the reverence the early Church held for their sacrifice.
They represent the countless Christians whose names the world has forgotten but whose confession Christ proclaims before the angels of heaven. Their feast urges us to imitate their courage: to endure reproach, to live by faith, and to confess Christ boldly.
Application for Today
• Endure with patience: Like the first Christians, do not grow weary under trials; remember the eternal reward.
• Fear God, not men: Live in holy reverence, valuing the soul above earthly security.
• Confess Christ boldly: Do not hide your faith; be willing to stand for truth even when it costs you.
• Look to the martyrs: Ask Sts. Protus and Hyacinth to intercede for courage in our times of trial.

Conclusionary Prayer
O Lord, who hast given us Sts. Protus and Hyacinth as shining examples of fidelity and courage, grant that, like them, we may endure reproach with patience and confess Thy holy name before men. Strengthen our faith, keep us steadfast in Tradition, and make us worthy to be confessed by Thee before the angels of God.
Sts. Protus and Hyacinth, pray for us.
Sacred Heart of Jesus, have mercy on us.
Immaculate Heart of Mary, intercede for us.