True Crime Stories: The Handprint That Haunted a Small Town

Step inside one of the most haunting true crime stories in recent memory. In this video, we follow the first police interview with Greg Mathu—a close friend of Doug and Nikki—whose timeline unravels before detectives. What begins as a casual night out turns into one of the most chilling true crime stories when Nikki mysteriously vanishes after a concert. As police uncover inconsistencies, handprints, and erratic phone calls, this case spirals into layers of doubt. With each minute, new threads emerge, placing Greg closer to a puzzle that no one can yet solve. This video sheds light on the raw emotional toll and psychological tension found in real true crime stories. If you're drawn to the shadows of truth and betrayal, this is one of those true crime stories you won’t forget. Watch now as we dissect the events behind one of Wisconsin’s most disturbing true crime stories.