When Persuasion Fails — Daily Persuasion with Joshua Lisec Ep. 284

Would you like to write a persuasive BOOK? One that changes minds and influencers behavior for years to come? Start with a GOLDEN book idea. Let NEW YORK TIMES bestselling author Joshua Lisec teach you: https://lisecghostwriting.com/golden

ABOUT TODAY'S EPISODE:

What do you do when persuasion doesn’t work—when the other person doesn’t want a win-win, but a win-lose?

In Episode 284 of Daily Persuasion with Joshua Lisec titled “When Persuasion Fails,” bestselling ghostwriter and persuasion expert Joshua Lisec explores what happens after persuasion hits a wall—and how real power negotiates with manipulators who have no intention of playing fair.

Persuasion is supposed to be simple: you offer something in honesty, the other person offers something in honesty, and both parties walk away better off. That’s the classic win-win. It’s how homogeneous high-trust societies—like the old-school handshake deal in Ohio—have always operated. This is what most people mean when they talk about ethical persuasion techniques, persuasion psychology, or how to persuade someone to do something with integrity.

But what happens when persuasion fails?

In this episode, Lisec explains that there are three modes of influence—not two. Everyone talks about manipulation versus persuasion—win-lose versus win-win. But there’s a third: lose-lose. Also known as mutually assured destruction, this is where persuasion doesn’t just fail—it gets obliterated by the other person’s refusal to play fair. When persuasion fails, you’re forced to choose between surrender or scorched earth.

Joshua Lisec shares real-world persuasion examples where people—especially men—get manipulated not by logic, but by shame, guilt, and emotional blackmail. He tells the story of a liberal feminist woman guilting her conservative fiancé out of asking her to take his last name. She doesn’t argue. She manipulates. She calls him sexist. She reframes a traditional marriage request as slavery. And when persuasion fails, what’s left? He calls off the wedding. Lose-lose. Mutually assured destruction.

This kind of atomic diplomacy is exactly the negotiation strategy Donald Trump has deployed in both politics and business. If you’re dealing with manipulators who aren’t looking for a mutual agreement, you don’t play persuasion. You play reciprocity. Not the sweet kind. The strategic reciprocity effect that says: “If you try to hurt me, I’m prepared to crash the whole car with you in it.”

That’s the takeaway from this week’s Daily Persuasion: when your opponent isn’t open to persuasive techniques, and traditional techniques of persuasion in writing or speech don’t work, your only move is reciprocity. Not just being kind when others are kind—but being equally unyielding when others are manipulative. Lisec calls it “Reciprocity, Maxine.”

If you’ve ever wondered “does persuasion work?” this episode will challenge your assumptions. Lisec explains what is reciprocity really, what is manipulation in practice—not theory—and how to build the internal strength to walk away when the deal turns toxic. You’ll hear persuasive techniques that are often mistaken for coercion—and how to distinguish between an ethical offer and emotional exploitation.

Along the way, Lisec weaves in examples of persuasion in advertising, in dating, and in politics. You'll learn the difference between “how to persuade someone to do something” honestly—and the darker arts of persuasive manipulation that ruin relationships and reputations.

Whether you’re a copywriter, a communicator, or just someone who’s tired of being gaslit in negotiations, Episode 284: “When Persuasion Fails” will give you the mental frameworks to spot manipulation early and the courage to burn it all down when necessary.

Watch now on Daily Persuasion with Joshua Lisec.

Because sometimes, persuasion fails. And when it does—you better know what to do next.