Red Dead Redemption Episode 5: Justice in Pike's Basin

"John stops by Marshal Johnson's office to speak to him. Before their conversation goes anywhere, Deputy Eli enters the office. Eli says that cattle rustlers have been spotted in Pike's Basin, just northeast of Armadillo."
"John finds Nigel West Dickens wounded in the desert near his stagecoach."
"Leigh Johnson asks John Marston to help in silencing a group of outlaws who have been terrorizing a town."