Cicero on Oratory - B2 - III IV

Cicero on Oratory - B2 - III IV

In this discourse, Cicero reflects on the complexities of oratory and the nature of eloquence, discussing the importance of public speaking and the pressures associated with it. He also highlights a gathering of notable figures discussing these themes, revealing insights into their thoughts on eloquence and the pressures of speaking in public.

Key Points:

Cicero's Self-Reflection on Eloquence
Cicero begins by addressing his brother and admits to feeling uncomfortable with public speaking, contrasting his eloquent language with his personal insecurities about its refinement. He acknowledges the influence of figures like Isocrates and suggests that the art of oration is nuanced and potentially intimidating for public figures.

Gathering of Influential Figures
The scene progresses as notable characters, including Quintus Catulus and Antonius, arrive to discuss eloquence and rhetoric. Their arrival is marked by a sense of anticipation, as Catulus comments on prior conversations with Cesar, indicating that the nature of eloquence was previously discussed in a manner akin to scholarly debate.

Impertinence in Conversation
Cicero elaborates on the concept of 'impertinence,' emphasizing that it arises from a failure to recognize the context or appropriateness of one’s discourse. He criticizes the Greek custom of engaging in complex debates even in unsuitable environments, contrasting it with Latin communication expectations and the significance of being pertinent in discussions.

Importance of Continuous Discussion
There is a desire expressed among the characters for fuller and continuous discussions on rhetoric, hinting at the collaborative nature of learning through dialogue. Cicero's internal struggle with his role and his reflections on what constitutes proper discussion illuminate the challenges faced by rhetoricians.