The Rant-Meritocracy of Awards?

The award season is a time to celebrate exceptional achievements and contributions in various fields. However, the debate over award selection criteria is growing. While diversity, equity, and inclusion are promoted, the fundamental principle should remain unwavering merit. Diluting this principle in favor of these initiatives risks undermining the integrity of awards and diminishing the significance of the accomplishments they celebrate. Awards serve as powerful motivators, validating years of dedication and innovative thinking. However, prioritizing diversity, equity, and inclusion over merit can devalue the accomplishments of those chosen, fueling skepticism and a feeling of tokenism. It is crucial to acknowledge that a lack of differences in award recipients often points to problems within the field.