2v1 DEBATE: Are the Shia Muslim? Should Sunnis Ally with Shia for Palestine?

DISCLAIMER: MuslimSkeptic condemns violence and all illegal groups and activities.

Hosted by ‪@ModernDayDebate‬ Subscribe!

Summary: Daniel Haqiqatjou debates two Sunni sectarians who do mass takfir of the Shia and believe Iran is a bigger threat to the Muslim world than Zionism.

DEBATE TOPICS:

1. What are the fiqh rules of takfir?
2. Do these rules justify general takfir of contemporary Twelver Shia?
3. Based on the rules of takfir, historical relations between Sunni and Shia, and current geopolitics, should contemporary Sunnis cooperate with Shia to defend Muslim lands?
4. What political stance is most appropriate for Sunnis to take: (1) alliance with Israel, the US, and their allies (2) alliance with Iran and its allies (3) no alliance with either group.

Support our work with a donation: https://muslimskeptic.com/contribute/
Join the newsletter: https://muslimskeptic.com/newsletter

MuslimSkeptic on Twitter: @muslimskeptichq

Daniel Haqiqatjou:

Twitter: @haqiqatjou
Telegram: https://t.me/haqiqatjou

0:00:00 Disclaimer
0:01:28 Sectarians Want Hijab
0:07:50 Daniel Opening 1
0:24:45 Wisam Opening
0:40:49 Appreciation for James and ‪@ModernDayDebate‬
0:41:42 Daniel Rebuttal
0:48:52 Wisam Rebuttal
0:54:16 CONCESSION - Wisam Admits that his takfir is only for Shia scholars not laymen
0:54:55 Open Discussion
1:09:30 Exposing Wisam's Insult of Sahaba
1:26:47 Mr. Potato-Head Opening
1:29:11 Mr. CONCESSION: Potato-Head he "willing to entertain" Iran and Shia are Muslim
1:43:26 Daniel Opening 2
1:59:10 Mr. Potato-Head Rebuttal
2:07:24 Daniel Rebuttal
2:12:50 Open Discussion
2:21:38 KUFR of Mr. Potato-Head
2:23:57 Mr. Potato-Head Disgusting Slander of the Prophet ﷺ
2:25:10 Mr. Potato-Head's Zionist Connections
2:25:38 Mr. Potato-Head Attacks Daniel's Sister
2:31:32 Mr. Potato-Head Insults ‪@MohammedHijab‬ and Sharia
2:37:12 DANIEL COOOKS (Explains Potato's Kufr)
2:40:35 Daniel Summarizes His Argument
2:42:45 Sectarians RUN After Getting Exposed
2:44:21 Superchats
2:53:00 Mr. Potato-Head Praises Saddam as Mass Murderer
2:55:04 Hadith on Unity
2:57:10 Why Shia Belief in Imams Is Not Clearly Kufr
3:04:09 Superchats
3:07:20 Daniel's Prep for Debate
3:10:00 Daniel Predicted EXACTLY How the Debate Would Go