Premium Only Content

Aliens, Social Groups, and the Golden Record | Jason Werbeloff
How would we explain our social structures to aliens? Can we define our social groups in a way that is easy to articulate and understand?
Jason Werbeloff argues that it’s extremely difficult to answer even the simplest questions about the nature of our social groups.
Does this mean we should exclude any talk of groups when describing ourselves on the Golden Record?
And should we understand ourselves as individuals, rather than as members of social groups?
00:00 Introduction and Welcome
00:21 The Voyager Golden Record
02:17 Philosophical Inquiry: Social Groups and Aliens
02:57 The Alien's Perspective on Social Groups
05:08 Defining Social Groups
12:25 Margaret Gilbert's Theory of Social Groups
14:16 Challenges to Gilbert's Theory
20:41 Alternative Theories and Eliminativism
27:08 Q&A and Further Discussion
36:20 The Vagueness of Group Identity
37:10 Dispositional Refinement and Group Membership
37:47 Challenges in Defining Group Membership
38:45 Moral Responsibility and Group Identity
40:08 Individual Accountability in Group Actions
44:09 Degrees of Group Membership
46:43 The Role of Group Leaders
48:56 Relational Properties and Group Persistence
01:05:41 Human Groups vs. Animal Groups
01:11:30 Concluding Thoughts
Presenters: Mark Oppenheimer and Jason Werbeloff
Editor and Producer: Ella Coleman
Brain in a Vat bookshop (Shopify): https://smarturl.it/BrainShop
Brain in a Vat bookshop (Amazon): https://smarturl.it/BrainAmazonShop
Podcast: https://anchor.fm/braininavat
Contact us: Mark.Oppenheimer[at]gmail and Jwerbe[at]gmail
-
1:57:40
The Charlie Kirk Show
3 hours agoWhere Do Rights Come From? + Lions and Scavengers + Midway Blitz | Shapiro, Yoo, McLaughlin | 9.9.25
30K10 -
1:19:45
The White House
5 hours agoPress Secretary Karoline Leavitt Briefs Members of the Media, Sep. 9, 2025
14.4K13 -
1:24:12
Mark Kaye
2 hours ago🔴 ICE Invades Chicago- Operation Midway Blitz
7.13K -
LIVE
Badlands Media
12 hours agoGeopolitics with Ghost Ep. 37- Sept. 9, 2025
955 watching -
4:07
Michael Heaver
3 hours agoBattered Germany Quickly Erupting Into PANIC
3.89K3 -
1:05:32
Timcast
3 hours agoNepal's Government COLLAPSES, Gen Z REVOLUTION Over Social Media Ban, 19 Dead
96.3K81 -
2:06:23
Steven Crowder
5 hours agoBrian Stelter's Delusional Response to the Charlotte Stabbing is Everything Wrong With Media
267K247 -
1:23:34
The Mel K Show
2 hours agoMORNINGS WITH MEL K - Suicidal Empathy, Denial of Truth & Rewriting History as a Weapon 9-9-25
17K3 -
1:15:30
Clownfish TV
3 hours agoXbox Game Pass Fail! Paranormal Chum Bucket, More! | DREZZED News Live
12.3K -
1:34:42
IrishBreakdown
3 hours agoNotre Dame vs Texas A&M Preview - Irish Must Show Grit In Home Opener
13.7K