Was Imam RA Hassan married with many infertile women | kiya imam ne baaanj lady sey shadi ki thi?

#hazratimamhassan #marriage #infertilewomen #muslimscholars

Asslamoalaikum sisters brothers friends and elders we are discribing about that Was Hazrat Imam Hassan married with many infertile women? | kiya hazrat imam husaain ne kafi baaanj lady sey shadi ki thi?

If someone assumes that: "Imam Hassan (peace be upon him) married infertile women, or they prevented pregnancies, or many children were born and later passed away," the response is clear. Firstly, such an assumption is not logically acceptable and seems highly unlikely it could be possible with few wives but not hundreds. Secondly, there is no historical record or report supporting this claim. Thus, the falsity of such claims becomes even more evident. It's not surprising that such cunning fabricators overlooked this point; Forgetfulness is a hallmark of liars. A liar has a weak memory; Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him) said: “One of the ways Allah assists against liars for the sake of the truth is through forgetfulness.”
Unknown Wives

Another reason to reject the aforementioned claim is that with all these wives attributed to Imam Hassan (peace be upon him), shouldn't at least half or 31 of them be identifiable by their parents, tribes, etc.? Yet, many of these alleged wives are so unknown that even their names remain a mystery.

Considering all the claimed wives attributed to the Imam (peace be upon him), it would make sense for him to have at least 50 daughters, and consequently, the same number of sons-in-law recorded. However, in this regard, only three sons-in-law have been introduced for the Imam:

Imam Zain al-Abidin RA, husband of Fatimah (Umm Abdullah);
Abdullah bin Zubair, husband of Umm al-Hassan;
Amro bin Mundhir, husband of Umm Salma.

Now the question arises: Is it plausible that from four hundred wives, only three or at most seven daughters were born, and only three of them got married with no trace of the others?

Clearly, if the claimed details were correct, history should have recorded many more children and sons-in-law for the Imam. However, as mentioned, only three sons-in-law of the Imam have been cited.

Comparison of Imam Hassan’s Era with the Present Time

Upon a careful comparison of the era of Imam Hassan (peace be upon him) with today’s age, the validity and credibility of the raised concerns are confirmed. This is because, despite modern economic conditions and the extensive global and regional advertising promoting population control – which has been very effective to the extent that according to a survey conducted in Germany, “65% of the respondents said they would prefer to have a dog than a child!”

However, despite this, it was recently reported in newspapers: “A man with twelve wives has forty children.” Of course, this news is just one example, and there have been many other instances seen or heard, such as a man with two wives having nineteen children or another man with four wives having forty children.

In summary, nowadays, the average number of children per woman is 3. Therefore, even with today’s statistics and all its limitations, a person who would have four hundred wives should have at least 1,200 children. However, for Imam Hassan (peace be upon him) during that specific time – when great importance was given to having many offspring, and they even took pride in it – a maximum of 31 children and only three sons-in-law are recorded. Hence, the above comparison also confirms and validates the falsehood of claims regarding Imam Hassan (peace be upon him) having numerous wives

Allah Hafiz