Math's Fundamental Flaw
Math's Fundamental Flaw
Not everything that is true can be proven. This discovery transformed infinity, changed the course of a world war and led to the modern computer.
Below is chapter 10 of my book "Google LDN !" In it I try to make Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem understandable to everybody.
10. Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem
At the risk of losing my audience, I wanted to cover this topic because I feel it underlies my justification for trying to cure my MS in an irrational way. If you start to haze over reading it, please just skip to the next chapter. While I try to explain it in a way that anyone can understand, I’m not sure how good a job I’ve done. I’m actually not sure that a good job can be done…
Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem is the granddaddy of them all, since it applies to mathematics which lies at the very core of all science. One could safely call mathematics the ultimate Aristotelian “First Philosophy” because it is basic to all science before one adds the particular details of any one science.
Gödel showed that within a rigidly logical system, propositions can be formulated that are undecidable or indemonstrable within the axioms of the system. That is, within the system, there exist certain clear-cut statements that can neither be proved nor disproved.
Hence one cannot, using the usual methods, be certain that the axioms of arithmetic will not lead to contradictions … It appears to foredoom hope of mathematical certitude through use of the obvious methods.
Perhaps doomed also, as a result, is the ideal of science - to devise a set of axioms from which all phenomena of the external world can be deduced.
Thus, Rationalism is by nature self-limited and unable to explain everything that happens to us in the world.
The bottom line is that Gödel’s incompleteness theorem gives me a rational basis to abandon Rationalism as my only source to seek a cure for this multiple sclerosis.
Why does this matter to me? It matters because of the subtitle of this book, “A Rationalist Seeks a Miracle Cure.” While that might appear to be self-contradictory at first, Gödel gives it meaning again.
I remain a rationalist, even though I acknowledge that Rationalism is self-limiting. Rationalism is still the best system ever devised for finding truth. It simply is incomplete, i.e. some truths must be found outside it.
Here’s Gödel’s proof in plain English:
1. Suppose we have a COMPUTER supposedly capable of correctly answering any question.
2. Now consider the following proposition:
“The COMPUTER will never say that this sentence is true.”
1. Now, what happens when we ask the COMPUTER whether that proposition is true?
2. If COMPUTER says it is true, then “COMPUTER will never say this sentence is true” is false.
3. If “COMPUTER will never say that this sentence is true” is false, then the proposition is false (since proposition = “COMPUTER will never say G is true“).
4. So if COMPUTER says the proposition is true, then the proposition is in fact false, and COMPUTER has made a false statement.
5. So COMPUTER will never say that the proposition is true, since COMPUTER makes only true statements.
6. We have established that COMPUTER will never say the proposition is true.
7. So “COMPUTER will never say the proposition is true” is in fact true.
8. So the proposition is true (since the proposition = “COMPUTER will never say that this sentence is true”).
9. We have thus produced a true statement which COMPUTER cannot make.
Therefore…
That ayahuasca may cure my MS, could well be a truth which Rationalism cannot support. However, what matters ultimately, is the truth. Not the method by which we arrive at it.
Bob thinks I have a neurotic and incorrect view of the meaning of Rationalism.
While I may indeed be neurotic, I think I understand rationalism about as well as it can be understood. Warts and all, it’s still the best system we’ve got. It’s just that it has failed me in this particular case. Gödel makes it possible for me to accept this.
-
58:11
The Why Files
4 days agoThe Search for Noah's Ark | Giants & Aliens in the Book of Enoch
144K142 -
2:15:43
vivafrei
21 hours agoFATHER'S DAY SPECIAL! Young Thug! Hunter Biden! 2nd Amendment! SCOTUS & MORE! Viva & Barnes!
153K237 -
LIVE
Vigilant News Network
19 hours agoMedia Blackout: 10 News Stories They Chose Not to Tell You - Episode 27
1,994 watching -
1:10:08
The Late Kick with Josh Pate
15 hours agoLate Kick Live Ep 522: CFB’s Loudest Stadiums | SEC Sleepers | Preseason Poll Ban | Recruiting Scoop
56.5K3 -
1:17:59
Game On!
18 hours agoSpecial Father's Day NFL Stream! Happy Father's Day Dads
88.1K9 -
43:20
Standpoint with Gabe Groisman
23 hours agoEp. 31. US Military Assessment of Gaza-Israel Conflict. Lt. Col. Geoffrey Corn
105K72 -
1:29:53
TheAlecLaceShow
1 day agoGuests: Vivek, MTG, Roger Stone, Mike Lindell & More | Live From Detroit | The Alec Lace Show
96.1K93 -
7:39
Sideserf Cake Studio
1 day ago $11.22 earnedA Hyperrealistic Cake on the Ceiling?! Celebrating 6 Million Subscribers!
127K23 -
1:04:23
Squaring The Circle w/ Randall Carlson
1 day ago#008 Are Sea Levels REALLY Rising? Pt 1 - Squaring the Circle: A Randall Carlson Podcast
120K76 -
8:31
Film Threat
1 day agoHOUSE OF THE DRAGON SEASON 2 EPISODES 1 & 2 | Film Threat Reviews
123K13