Premium Only Content

Potato Surprise
Potato Surprise is the perfect side dish and can even be the main meal. Once you try this recipe, you will be wanting to make it again and again!!
This is one of those recipes that you can easily tweak to make it your own. By adding different meats and cheeses, or using different kinds of potato, you can create an excellent side dish that your family will love.
Meat and Dry Rub was provided by Lobel's of New York:
http://www.lobels.com
https://www.lobels.com/Linguica-1102
https://www.lobels.com/lobels-all-purpose-savory-seasoning-887
Surprise Potatoes Recipe (Feeds 12)
5 pounds potatoes (use your favorite type of potato)
1 Can (14.5 oz) Cream of Mushroom Soup
1 Can (14.5 oz) Cream of Chicken Soup
1 Cup Sour Cream
1/4 Cup of Lobel's Dry Rub (or your favorite BBQ Rub)
1/8 Cup Garlic Powder
2 Cups Cheddar Cheese (reserve 1/2 cup for topping)
1/8 Cup Paprika (or top casserole with more BBQ Rub)
1 Pound of leftover BBQ meat (Pulled Pork, Brisket, Chicken, Turkey, Sausage, etc.)
Salt & Black Pepper to taste
1) Boil potatoes until fork tender. (20-40 mins depending on size)
2) Drain cooked potatoes and place into a mixing bowl. Break up potatoes or mash them to the consistency that you like.
3) Add both soups, sour cream, BBQ Rub, Garlic Powder, Cheese, and meat to the potatoes. Mix thoroughly.
4) Scoop mixture into a baking dish and smooth out the top. Add remaining cheese and paprika (or more BBQ Rub) as a topping for the casserole.
5) Cover loosely with tin foil and bake at 225F for 1 1/2 or until all of the cheese is melted. Enjoy!!!
Optional:
You can place the potato mixture into a large foil pan and cook it on your bbq pit or smoker to add some smoke flavor. Cook for the same amount of time at 225F if cooking on your outdoor cooker.
Follow T-Roy Cooks:
Facebook: www.facebook.com/TroyCooksGoodFood
Twitter: twitter.com/T_ROY_COOKS
Pinterest: www.pinterest.com/spacecowboytx
Music:
"Nile's Blues"
Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
-
13:10
TroyCooks
1 year agoTour of my new Lone Star Grillz 24x40 offset with Stainless Steel Grates and 1st Cook!!!
147 -
LIVE
The Jimmy Dore Show
32 minutes agoThe REAL Reason Behind El Salvador Deportations! EU Preps Europeans For Nuclear War! w/ Max Keiser
7,502 watching -
LIVE
Dr Disrespect
4 hours ago🔴LIVE - DR DISRESPECT - TRIPLE THREAT CHALLENGE - WZ, PUBG, TARKOV
23,737 watching -
LIVE
Nerdrotic
2 hours agoSnow White BOMBS, Marvel Desperation, Amazon Studio Head QUITS! - Friday Night Tights 347
2,188 watching -
DVR
In The Litter Box w/ Jewels & Catturd
21 hours agoTRUMP WALKS THE TALK | In the Litter Box w/ Jewels & Catturd – Ep. 772 – 3/28/2025
10.6K20 -
14:11
Talk Nerdy Sports - The Ultimate Sports Betting Podcast
28 minutes ago3/28/25 -Fire Friday: 5 Bets, 3 Parlays & 1 Stone Cold Lock That Books Fear
-
2:54:49
Right Side Broadcasting Network
3 hours agoLIVE: President Trump Participates in the Swearing-In Ceremony for Alina Habba - 3/28/25
43.8K11 -
LIVE
Barry Cunningham
3 hours agoTGIF! TRUMP WINNING! DEMOCRATS ARE LOST LOSERS! | LOTS MORE NEWS!
1,651 watching -
11:07
MrBigKid
2 hours agoRuger RXM... ALL-METAL. The Icarus Precision Grip Module
14 -
17:23
Silver Dragons
2 hours agoDealer EXPOSES Fake Silver Scam (All Silver Tests Revealed)
1363