The Myth Of American Meritocracy (5-4-18)
http://lukeford.net/blog/?p=121912, http://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/the-myth-of-american-meritocracy/ Andrew Gelman writes: This news story reminded me of some threads from a few years ago about Ron Unz, the political activist who wrote a statistics-filled article a few years ago claiming that Harvard and other Ivy League colleges discriminate against Asian-Americans and in favor of Jews in undergraduate admissions. It turned out that some of his numbers were off by factors of 2 or 4 or more, and then, amusingly, or horrifyingly, Unz offhandedly remarked that one of his more high-profile statistical claims (cited in a notorious New York Times column by David Brooks) had been based on “five minutes of cursory surname analysis.”
Unz really pulled the rug out from Brooks on that one! The world-famous Ted Talk speaker and humility expert was too proud to retract his column, so Unz had left him to twist slowly in the wind. (Hence the image above; if we’re gonna mix metaphors I might as well go whole hog.)
In all seriousness, I remain upset by the way that false claims can stick in the public discourse. Nothing new here, of course (insert Twain-attributed quote here) but particularly sad in this case in that I expect the numbers in question were not lies but rather mere mistakes.
At some point I have more to say about this case as an example of how certain intuitions can lead us astray—believe it or not, I see some connections between the reasoning of Unz and Brooks and that of authors of various unreplicated papers in social psychology.
-
1:34:13
jeffahern
3 hours agoThursday Thrash with Jeff Ahern (9am Pacific)
11.2K -
1:18:41
Trumpet Daily
2 hours agoTrumpet Daily | May 9, 2024
18.7K7 -
1:30:14
Benny Johnson
3 hours agoTrump Trial 'Star Witness' Referred to DOJ for PRISON! Stormy Daniels TIRE FIRE Testimony BLOWS UP🔥
61.1K111 -
1:06:17
Geeks + Gamers
4 hours agoFans Are DONE With Woke Disney, Star Wars Gets DESTROYED For Pushing Agenda In New Show | G+G Daily
23.1K4 -
2:09:26
The Kirk Minihane Show
6 hours agoKMS Live - May 9, 2024
28.8K -
2:05:52
Matt Kohrs
14 hours agoTrump Backs Crypto, Stocks on Edge & Live Trading || The MK Show
35.1K1 -
2:28:59
Due Dissidence
15 hours agoIsraeli Spokesman CRUMBLES on Piers Morgan, Student Protester SCHOOLS Media, Seinfeld's Movie TANKS
31.1K48 -
48:11
Rethinking the Dollar
4 hours agoDigital Revolution: A Bank Stops Cash Services (People Forced To Rethink Banking)
20.3K3 -
1:37:53
The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters
8 hours agoThe Podcast of the Lotus Eaters #911
49.6K29 -
2:58:21
Wendy Bell Radio
9 hours agoThe Democrat Dreamscape
65.3K110