Recreating Tolkien | On Activist Fandom and the Rings of Power

Save
3 years ago
15

You've probably heard of the "Purist" fans of Tolkien--those who only and always hew closely to Tolkien's exact writings. Today, there's another stripe of fandom: the activistis.

Jonathan, Michael, and Dan engage in a discussion, posing the question, will activist fandom eventually destroy Tolkien?

——————————————————
Tolkien Resources 🔎
——————————————————
Listen to our Podcast â–º https://www.windowonthewest.com

Get The Silmarillion â–º https://amzn.to/3a7wE0k
Get The Atlas of Middle-earth â–º https://amzn.to/3lzsIIf

Get more Tolkien â–º https://www.theonering.com

——————————————————
Chapters
——————————————————
00:00 Introduction
00:10 Will activist fandom eventually destroy Tolkien?
03:00 The Activist Lens
06:18 Projectionism is the Problem
07:40 Lord of the Rings isn't Christian?
09:14 The Black Hole of Activism
12:20 When you project, you cheapen it
13:45 Don't let the labels get to you
14:20 Story shouldn't be a vehicle for the message
15:10 Pure narcissism
16:40 Star Wars has already been destroyed
17:05 Tolkien needs to stay Tolkien
10:20 Hobbits from Skid Row
10:45 The Hobbits are a diversity grab
13:04 "If you can't see it, you can't be it"
13:45 We're skeptical. Are you?

Loading comments...