Premium Only Content

The Circleville Letters Mystery | Why can't we solve this?
MYSTERY OF THE CIRCLEVILLE LETTERS
We all keep secrets.
For most of us, these are nothing more than minor embarrassing details about ourselves. But some of us have dark secrets which, if discovered, could destroy lives.
For years, the residents of Circleville, Ohio, received bizarre, threatening letters; from someone who somehow knew every salacious detail of their personal lives.
The letters cost people their jobs, their marriages, their freedom, and sometimes, their lives.
Over a thousand letters were sent over *20 years*.
Yet somehow, whoever wrote them got away with it. Or did they?
Officially this case is closed. But for decades, many people felt that the real culprit is still at large.
Let's find out why.
---
🙏 SUPPORT THE WHY FILES
🙏 https://www.patreon.com/thewhyfiles (Fun, Free Perks!)
👽 BUY WHY FILES MERCH
👽 https://shop.thewhyfiles.com (Code: LIZZIDPEEPLE for 10% off first order)
💬 CHAT WITH US ON DISCORD
💬 https://thewhyfiles.com/discord
〰
🌐 OFFICIAL WEB SITE: https://thewhyfiles.com
🕵️ Submit a topic, suggestion or just say hi:
🕵️ https://thewhyfiles.com/tips
🎨 Have a product suggestion or want to design artwork for TWF?
🎨 https://thewhyfiles.com/merch
📸 BE A WHY FILES MODEL (and get free stuff!)
📸 Send a photo of you/family/friends watching TWF,
📸 wearing TWF gear, using TWF merchandise:
📸 https://thewhyfiles.com/wild
〰
🎧 THE PODCAST VERSION
🎧 https://thewhyfiles.com/podcast
〰
⁍ TWF on SOCIAL (in order of importance)
⁍ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheWhyFiles/
⁍ https://twitter.com/OMGTheWhyFiles
⁍ https://www.instagram.com/OMGTheWhyFiles
⁍ https://www.tiktok.com/@thewhyfiles
⁍ https://www.facebook.com/OMGTheWhyFiles
〰
🐠 BETTER CHANNELS TO WATCH:
🐠 https://www.youtube.com/c/HecklefishMoriarty
🤓 https://www.youtube.com/c/TheWhyFilesBackstage
----
SOURCES & LINKS
http://www.encyclopediaofalabama.org/article/h-3033
#unsolvedmysteries #truecrime #circleville
-
50:02
The Why Files
29 days agoProject Pegasus | The CIA's Child Time Soldiers
87.3K80 -
2:11:14
Redacted News
2 hours agoArrest Hillary Clinton!?! Here we go! | Redacted News Live
100K61 -
LIVE
Kimberly Guilfoyle
2 hours ago"Burns Bags" at FBI, What's Next? Interview with Former Agent John Nantz | Ep242
739 watching -
LIVE
RalliedLIVE
1 day ago $2.89 earnedBattlefield 6 REVEAL w/ Ral
593 watching -
44:45
The White House
2 hours agoPresident Trump Signs an Executive Order, July 31, 2025
13.5K14 -
LIVE
Sarah Westall
1 hour ago“This Conversation Would Land Me in Prison in Ireland” - Its the Global Plan w/ Captain Kieran Kelly
404 watching -
1:15:42
vivafrei
3 hours agoPelosi Doth Protest Too Much! "Trans" Athlete Plot to Harm Female? Crooked hillary Cooked & MORE
87.4K24 -
1:42:17
The Quartering
5 hours agoHillary Clinton FINALLY BUSTED, Nancy Pelosi MELTDOWN, Kamala Harris Admits Defeat & More
116K72 -
3:10:42
Barry Cunningham
9 hours agoMUST SEE: KAROLINE LEAVITT HOSTS WHITE HOUSE PRESS CONFERENCE ( AND MORE NEWS)
57.6K25 -
53:03
Sean Unpaved
6 hours agoSchlereth Unplugged: 3x Champ Talks TV, Football, & 2025 Season Expectations
42.7K1