Is the Sermon on the Mount a literary creation? A response to Mike Winger (and Michael Jones)
Pastor Mike Winger seems to think that the Sermon on the Mount and the Sermon on the Plain were actual sermons given word-for-word by the historical Jesus on two different occasions. In this video, I walk through some of the reasons for thinking the Sermon on the Mount is in fact a literary creation of the first evangelist. Along the way, I also respond briefly to Michael Jones regarding the missionary discourse in the Synoptics.
Mike Winger's videos:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OhV-q2DS-bU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePKWFPESfZs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-GAGA9wnJ7k
Michael Jones's video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDzHMe7Bb60
Errata:
1. In the quote I read by Christopher Tuckett, I forgot to mention that even though he was talking about the Griesbach hypothesis, his point is still valid on any Synoptic hypothesis where Matthew is not an eyewitness.
2. In the Gruen quote, I mis-pronounce "progress". Oops!
Image credits:
https://4000jesuspictures.com/704-jesus-children/kingdom-of-heaven/otto-a-stemler-01.jpg.html
https://www.ncregister.com/blog/was-st-peter-the-greatest-disciple
https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103RG2
0:00 Intro
0:55 The scholarly view
3:37 How ancient authors remembered speeches
10:00 How the Synoptic authors used their sources
16:08 A contradiction in the Missionary Discourse
18:31 The Sermon on the Mount
19:40 Conclusion
-
7:37
The Joe Rogan Experience Podcast
11 months agoWhat Killer Mike Would Say to the Authors of the Bible
5.3K12 -
1:13:47
ChurchoftheFormerdaySaints
5 months agoMike Winger Response 4: Hebrews Chapter 1: MBS Special
27 -
2:13:20
Daily Excellence
6 months ago $1.25 earnedMike From COT - Revelation Discussion 11/29/23
1.46K3 -
36:37
JackBBosma
1 year agoMeet Your Greatness Mike Fearn Creator / Author
2 -
1:58:05
Daily Excellence
2 years ago $0.02 earnedBook Of Peter, God's Longsuffering With Mike From COT 01:24:22
871 -
1:44:21
ChurchoftheFormerdaySaints
4 months agoMike Winger Response 6: Hebrews Chapters 4:14-7:11: MBS Special
51 -
1:24:38
ChurchoftheFormerdaySaints
4 months agoMike Winger Response 7: Hebrews Chapters 7: MBS Special
581 -
58:22
ChurchoftheFormerdaySaints
5 months agoMike Winger Response 5: Hebrews Chapters 2-4: MBS Special
20 -
1:03:26
The Remnant Radio
7 months agoInterview with Tim Mackie from The Bible Project | Sermon on the Mount
205 -
2:09:59
Daily Excellence
5 months ago $0.33 earnedMike For COT Revelation Chapter 4-7 Study 12/29/23
1.13K