Premium Only Content

Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pie Recipe - Easy to make and SO delicious!
I love this old fashioned buttermilk pie recipe! This quintessential southern pie is a perfect spring or summertime dessert, although it's delicious anytime! It's super easy to make. You really can't get it wrong! And you just need a few ingredients.
Some people keep this refrigerated (like myself). Others keep it out on the counter. Do what you like, but regardless of how you store it, I can't imagine it will be around longer than a day or two!
Here's how to make this delicious old-fashioned, homemade buttermilk pie.
INGREDIENTS
1 cup sugar
2 eggs
1/2 cup butter, melted
1 cup buttermilk
2 tsp. vanilla
1 Tbsp. flour
1/4 tsp. salt
INSTRUCTIONS
1. Preheat oven to 350º.
2. Mix together all ingredients.
3. Pour into pie shell and bake at 350º for 50 minutes.
4. Turn oven temp down to 325º and bake for an additional 10 minutes.
5. Take pie out of oven and let come down to room temperature and chill before serving. (This pie should not be eaten hot. It's much better when it's cool.)
Enjoy!
Here's how I make homemade vanilla extract: https://www.oldtimeknowledge.com/make-your-own-vanilla-extract/
-
8:46
Old Time Knowledge
2 years agoStarbucks style Pumpkin Bread - Pumpkin Loaf! Pumpkin spice & sunflower seeds - Fall recipes 🍂🎃
105 -
2:00:33
Joker Effect
3 hours agoSoo @MrBeast charity, is it legit? XenaTheWitch got attested? Lets talk about it! HOW TO GO VIRAL.
18.8K1 -
27:01
TheRoyaltyAutoService
10 hours ago $0.06 earnedAnother Shop Replaced The Timing Belt & Fuel Injectors On This Honda Pilot… Now It Has No Power!
31.9K3 -
10:14:25
GritsGG
12 hours agoRanked Crim 2! Most Wins 3390+ 🧠
62.7K -
3:12:37
IsaiahLCarter
1 day ago $1.69 earnedJonah O. Wheeler: In Defense of Reality || APOSTATE RADIO #026
31.4K1 -
LIVE
Cewpins
6 hours agoSmoke Sesh🔥Gaming???💨420🍃!MJ !giveaway
158 watching -
LIVE
Phyxicx
5 hours agoShin Megami Tensei - Part 5 - 8/13/2025 | Chaos Route | Expert Difficulty
100 watching -
1:59:32
vivafrei
15 hours agoEp. 277: Russia Peace Talks! Trump D.C. Takeover Leads to Lawsuit! Heat Wave Lawsuit? AND MORE!
84.5K116 -
2:17:57
Nerdrotic
7 hours ago $0.22 earnedTransient Lunar Phenomenon: Deeper into the Mysteries of the Moon | Forbidden Frontier #112
27.1K3 -
2:58:44
Barry Cunningham
1 day agoBREAKING NEWS: PRESIDENT TRUMP ABSOLUTELY TROLLS THE MEDIA! BIG WEEK AHEAD!
75.4K108