ICASA vs Malapane 4 20220506 b
ICASA vs Malapane
Case number: JR 1696/17
Citation: [2022] ZALCJHB 90 (7 April 2022)
A vehicle, allocated by an employer, is stolen while parked in the employee’s garage at his home. The employee made a statement to the police and a completely different statement to the employer about the theft.
The employer dismissed the employee two years later and offset a student loan debt due by the employee to the employer against his final income on termination.
The CCMA reinstated the employee and ordered a reimbursement of the student loan debt. The Labour Court, on Reviewing the CCMA Award:
ONE: Assessed the employer’s and employee’s conflicting versions against the principles set out in the Supreme Court of Appeal judgement of Stellenbosch Farmers’ Winery Group v Martell, 2003 (1) SA 11
TWO: Considered the fairness of the process and the sanction of dismissal, in the light of the two-year delay, against the principles set out in the Labour Court judgement of Moroenyane v Station Commander of SAPS, Vanderbijlpark [2016] JOL 36595
THREE: Considered whether the CCMA had the authority, in terms of section 74(2) of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA), to order the reimbursement of the student loan debt.
-
29:42
Breaking Points
1 hour ago6/25/24: LIVE AMA!
901 -
1:25:16
Graham Allen
3 hours agoCNN Threatening To STOP ALL Debate Coverage! + Info Wars Being SHUTDOWN!
25.2K94 -
2:02:27
Matt Kohrs
12 hours agoStocks Waver, Bitcoin Bounces Back & Live Trading || The MK Show
15.9K2 -
1:49:36
Bussin' With The Boys
10 hours agoTravis Kelce Talks Dating Taylor Swift + Winning Back To Back Super Bowls
9.09K9 -
LIVE
Wendy Bell Radio
6 hours agoTapped Out
9,139 watching -
3:20:55
SNEAKO
11 hours agoLS LATE NIGHT - SECRET GUEST, DRAMA, AUTISM
83K84 -
3:06:28
Fresh and Fit
12 hours agoDo Sex Workers Deserve A Good Man?! HEATED DEBATE!
151K201 -
16:39
Stephen Gardner
13 hours ago🔴Breaking: Trump GETS HUGE boost as Jesse Waters Humiliates Biden!
63.4K80 -
39:42
Candace Owens
18 hours agoChrissy Teigen Needs An Exorcism | Candace Ep 11
87.6K147 -
2:32:24
Fresh and Fit
18 hours agoHow To Start A Business With NO MONEY!
118K17