Why Popes Should Stay Off Social Media (and Stop Giving Interviews)

Popes should not be on social media platforms or granting journalistic interviews.

Both mediums create confusion, water down the message, and fail to convey the depth of the Catholic faith.

The Problem with Social Media

• Papal tweets/posts are often bland, inoffensive, and sometimes not recognizably Christian.
• The brevity required on platforms like Twitter reduces doctrine to pablum.
• Soundbites can be easily misinterpreted or weaponized by media outlets.

A Brief History of Papal Interviews

• 1892 — Pope Leo XIII interviewed by French journalist Séverin; caused significant controversy and confusion. Not repeated for decades.
• 1960s — Pope Paul VI granted two interviews with writers; reopened questions about papal communication and authority.
• 1994 — Pope John Paul II interviewed by Vittorio Messori for Crossing the Threshold of Hope; created uncertainty about how authoritative papal interviews are meant to be.
• 2013–present — Pope Francis: a torrent of interviews, off-the-cuff remarks, and informal settings that have generated widespread doctrinal confusion.

Key Problems With Papal Interviews

• Lack of clarity: informal answers can contradict or obscure settled teaching.
• Uncertainty of authority: are interviews magisterial, personal opinion, or something in between?
• Media distortion: quotes are often lifted out of context and sensationalized.
• Damage to credibility: casual remarks undermine the gravitas of the papal office.

Conclusion

• The Pope’s role is to preserve, defend, and teach the faith—not to be a media celebrity.
• Social media and interviews blur the lines between timeless doctrine and fleeting commentary.
• The Church needs clarity, not confusion; reverence, not soundbites.

Join the True North community! www.patrickcoffin.media