May 20, 2023

The fourth tall tale you will be tasked to complete in Season 3: A Pirate’s Life in Sea of Thieves is called The Dark Brethren. You will follow Jack Sparrow on yet another adventure that relates back to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, and this time Davy Jones is involved. You will be tasked with solving puzzles, finding journals, revealing murals, and battling enemies.

It is easy to miss something along the way that could grant you a commendation, while other parts of this tall tale are simply confusing. You will complete it in no time by following the right steps so you only have to complete the Dark Brethren Tall Tale once in Sea of Thieves.

All of the tall tales this season ask you to start off by talking with The Castaway at an outpost, then you must interact with the shelf on the far right that has the chain on the bottom shelf in order to vote for the tall tale.

This will spawn a cutscene with the castaway and Jack Sparrow, where he will then join you on your ship as you begin your next adventure.